Amazon Groups Fight U.S. Call for Forced Contact with Remote Tribes*

Amazon Groups Fight U.S. Call for Forced Contact with Remote Tribes*

Amazon Groups Fight U.S. Call for Forced Contact with Remote Tribes*


Indigenous people attend a public hearing on human rights issues in Brasilia, Brazil. | Photo: Creative Commons

U.S. academics Robert Walker and Kim Hall’s proposal to force “controlled contact” on voluntarily isolated tribes would be dangerous, critics say.

Amazonian Indigenous leaders have firmly rejected a proposal by U.S. anthropologists to force uncontacted peoples in the Amazon to come into contact with the rest of society in a “controlled” way, warning such a move would be detrimental to isolated groups and could prompt a “genocide” against Indigenous peoples.

The proposal is both dangerous and illegal, and undermines the rights that Indigenous peoples have fought long and hard for,” wrote a group of 10 Indigenous organizations from Brazil, Paraguay, and Peru in a letter to “wholeheartedly reject” the call from U.S. anthropologists Robert Walker and Kim Hill to force contact with uncontacted groups.

The University of Missouri’s Walker and Arizona State University’s Hill sparked controversy in the anthropology community last year with their contentious proposal to do away with established protocol on uncontacted groups, which is to leave them alone unless they decide to make contact with the outside world. The rogue anthropologists argue that uncontacted tribes reject contact out of fear, and that “controlled” interaction with the outside world is the only way to avert a disaster that could come to pass with eventually inevitable contact.

But the Indigenous groups that have come together to reject the proposal and to call on Walker and Hill to retract their statements.

“The anthropologists claim that uncontacted tribes are unviable, but this dangerous myth plays into the hands of those who wish to invade and exploit tribal people’s ancestral homelands,” the organizations wrote in the letter, published on Survival International’s website.

“The real threats against uncontacted tribes’ futures are genocidal violence, the invasion of their lands and theft of their natural resources, and prevailing racist attitudes,” they continue.

According to Survival International, the Amazon is home to some 100 uncontacted tribes. Various Indigenous groups fighting to protect their own rights as well as the rights of uncontacted peoples’ have spoken up in defence of their isolated counterparts.

In a video released by Survival International, Guajajara Indian leader Olimpio Guajajara said his people and the organization they call the Guajajara Guardians are committed to protecting the nearby uncontacted Awa tribe and reject Walker and Hill’s proposal.

“We will not allow this to happen,” he said, making specific reference to the call for “controlled contact” with groups in voluntary isolation.

“Because it would be another genocide of Indigenous people who do not want contact neither with us nor with non-Indigenous people.”

Survival International argues that so-called “controlled contact” would pave the way for Amazonian tribes to be easily exploited by logging and ranching interests and corporate land grabs, robbing them of their Indigenous land rights.

According to a report by the Inter-American Commission for Human Rights on Indigenous people living in voluntary isolation or with limited contact in the Americas, anthropological research has shown that the traumatic effects of often-violent contact can transcend several generations and lead isolated groups to further reject contact with the outside world.


Related Topics:

Amazonian Elders Conclude Completion of First Indigenous Medical Encyclopaedia*

Police Killing Indigenous Americans at Astounding Rate*

Indigenous Activists Chase McCain off the Navajo Land he intends to Mine*

Brazil vs. the Indigenous Fight against the Belo Monte Dam*

Brazil: Corporations Continue to Seize Indigenous Lands and Hire Hit Men to Murder Residents

EPA from Congress on Toxic Mine waste Spilt in Indigenous Waterways*

Obama Changes Mountain’s Name to Its’ Indigenous Name, but Continues to Steal Indigenous Land*

Indigenous Americans against the Canonization of Junípero Serra*

Indigenous Canadians Sue Government over White Adoptions*

Eugenics: Kidnapping of the Indigenous Sioux in South Dakota*

Canada Forcing the Indigenous to Give Up their Land*

The Vanishing Indigenous Nations of the U.S. – Five Facts*

Australians Rally against Kicking the Indigenous off their Own Land*

Indigenous Australians being Starved by their Occupiers*

US Vaporized and Experimented on the Indigenous of Marshall Islands*

Greed Trumps Justice: Indigenous Tribe Stripped of Their Native Lands – Over Gold*

Indigenous Communities Forcefully Removed for U.N. Sponsored Panama Dam*

Pope Francis to Get the Doctrine of Destiny (Inter Caetera Papal Bull) Revoked*

Indigenous Communities in Guatemala Fight against the Privatization of Sacred Sites*


Published by: curi56

Fighting for justice means fighting for justice for all of us and not playing around with the colour of skin. Focus on justice. i am a scientist for educ./psychoanalysis/art - and frankly speaking a savant - discovered that I can do more with blogs & social networks for humans in shadow, children in shadow, animals in need et al - I have some more blogs, please, visit them p.e.: Curi56blog et al. I am glad to meet YOU here: Annamaria thank you Annamaria

1 Comment

One thought on “Amazon Groups Fight U.S. Call for Forced Contact with Remote Tribes*”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s